All Gourmet Desserts

View as:
Grid List
Sort by:
Per Page:

Original Plain Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$50.95

9”

SERVES16

OP9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Apple Bavarian Tart

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

AB10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Carrot Cake

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

CARROT10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$50.95

9”

SERVES16

CC9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Chocolate Lover's Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES14

CLS9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake made with Snickers® Bars

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES14

CN9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake made with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups®

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES14

CPB9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
E Gift Certificate sent via email

Availability: In Stock

$0.00

SERVESany

ECERT

Availability: In Stock

View

View
Half & Half Sampler - Plain and Strawberry

Availability: In Stock

$55.95

9”

SERVES16

HH9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Lemon Mixed Berry Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

LM10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Moscato Berry Tira Mi Su

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

MB10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
12 Month Cheesecake Club

Availability: In Stock

$595.95

SERVES14-16

MO

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
3 Month Cheesecake Club

Availability: In Stock

$139.95

SERVES14-16

MO3

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
6 Month Cheesecake Club

Availability: In Stock

$295.95

SERVES14-16

MO6

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Neapolitan Tower

Availability: In Stock

$100.95

SERVES40

NT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Original Favorites Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES16

OS9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Party Pack - Original/Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$93.95

SERVES32

PARTYPACK

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Red Eli's T-Shirt

Availability: In Stock

$14.00

SERVES

REDT

Availability: In Stock

View

View
Salted Caramel Cheesecake made with Gluten Free Ingredients

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES14

SALTCARM

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Strawberry-Topped Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$55.95

9”

SERVES16

SW9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Old-Fashioned Triple Chocolate Cake

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

TCC10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Tira Mi Su

Availability: In Stock

$63.95

9”

SERVES14

TM9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Tres Leches Cake

Availability: In Stock

$63.95

9”

SERVES14

TRES9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Tower of Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$100.95

SERVES40

TW

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Key Lime Pie Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

KLPIE

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath® Toffee Bars

Availability: In Stock

$55.95

9”

SERVES14

HB9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
C-CAKE - Design Your Own Cake

Availability: In Stock

$76.95

9”

SERVES16

ccake

Availability: In Stock

View

View
Tuxedo Sampler Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$65.95

9”

SERVES14

TUXSAMP

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Midwest Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

8”

SERVES12

MIDSAMP

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack

Availability: In Stock

$33.95

SERVES12

PIEAC2

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Double Dipper® Pack

Availability: In Stock

$74.95

SERVES12

ED2

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook

Availability: In Stock

$26.00

SERVES

CBOOK

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Apple Streusel Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$41.95

8”

SERVES14

ASTR8

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Buffet Tower

Availability: In Stock

$90.95

SERVES20

BUFTWR

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook and Cheesecake Tower

Availability: In Stock

$116.00

SERVES30

CBTWR

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Cookbook Gift Packs

Availability: In Stock

$

9”

SERVESVaries

BOOKGIFT

Availability: In Stock

View

View
Layer Cake Club

Availability: In Stock

$269.95

SERVES14 each

LAYERCLUB

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Seasonal Cheesecake Club

Availability: In Stock

$209.95

SERVES14 each

SEASON

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
8" Original Plain Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$41.95

8”

SERVES14

OP8

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
8" White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$41.95

8”

SERVES14

WCR8

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Chocolate Hazelnut Crisp Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

9”

SERVES14

HAZCRISP9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Cheesecake Cuties

Availability: In Stock

$39.95

SERVES12 cuties per box

12CUTIES

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Chicago-Style Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

SERVES12

CHISTYLE8

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
DIY Wedding Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$165.95

SERVES40

DIYWED

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$33.95

7”

SERVES12

NSAPLAIN

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Mini Fudge Brownies

Availability: In Stock

$29.95

SERVES12 brownies per box

BROWNIECUTIES

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Cutie Dessert Sampler

Availability: In Stock

$39.95

SERVES12 cuties per box

CUTIESAMP

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars

Availability: In Stock

$42.95

SERVES10 bars per tin

DBLMARSH

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Kids' Apron

Availability: In Stock

$29.00

SERVESOne Size

APRONKID

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Chef Hat

Availability: In Stock

$19.00

SERVESOne Size

CHEFHAT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Cheesecake Cuties Gift Set

Availability: In Stock

$69.95

SERVES24 cuties per box

24CUTIES

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Sampler Club

Availability: In Stock

$219.95

SERVES14-16

SAMPCLUB

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Deep Dish Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$55.95

SERVES8

DEEPDISH9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut

Availability: In Stock

$50.95

SERVES16

PLAINUC

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Confetti Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$58.95

9”

SERVES14

CONFETTI9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
8" Turtle Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$41.95

8”

SERVES14

TURTLE8

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

Basque Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

8”

SERVES14

BASQ

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Goat Cheese Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$49.95

8”

SERVES14

GOAT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Vegan Dairy-Free Lemon Raspberry Cheesecake Cuties

Availability: In Stock

$39.95

SERVES12

LEMCUTIE

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

PP10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Mini Macaroons

Availability: In Stock

$33.95

SERVES12

12MACAROON

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Pecan Bars

Availability: In Stock

$33.95

SERVES12

PECANB

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

I Heart Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$51.95

SERVES12

IHEART

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
DIY Marshmallow Crispy Bar Decorating Kit

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

SERVES24

CRISPYKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Birthday Celebrate-at-Home Party Kit - Confetti Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$64.95

9”

SERVES14

CONBDKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Birthday Celebrate-at-Home Party Kit - Chocolate Cake

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

8”

SERVES12

CHOCBDKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Graduation Celebrate-at-Home Kit

Availability: In Stock

$64.95

9”

SERVES14

GRADKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

Rep Your Colors Cake - Design Your Own

Availability: In Stock

$71.95

9”

SERVES16

GRADCCAKE

Availability: In Stock

View

View
Chocolate Cheesecake Heart

Availability: In Stock

$51.95

SERVES8

CHCUBIEHRT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

Ruby Jubilee Cheesecake

Availability: In Stock

$59.95

SERVES14

RUBY9

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

Thanksgiving Half and Half - 10 inch

Availability: In Stock

$80.95

SERVES14

THANKSHALF10

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

DIY Holiday Cuties Kit

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

SERVES24

DIYHOLKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

DIY Winter Wonderland Cuties Kit

Availability: In Stock

$45.95

SERVES24

DIYWINTERKIT

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
new item

Holiday Cuties

Availability: In Stock

$39.95

SERVES12 cuties per box

12HOLIDAY

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View
Candy Cane Lane Tower. Available beginning in December!
Our most festive tower! Includes an

new item

Anniversary Tower

Availability: In Stock

$90.95

SERVES40

ANNTOW

Availability: In Stock

Qty.

View