All Desserts
-
On Sale
DIY Winter Wonderland Cheesecake Cuties Kit
(Serves 24)$48.95$43.95 -
On Sale
Holiday Cuties
(Serves 12 cuties per box)$42.95$34.95 -
On Sale
Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake Dipper
(Serves 6)$52.95$39.95 -
On Sale
Best of Eli's Holiday Pack
(Serves 35)$93.95$85.95 -
On Sale
Candy Cane Lane Tower
(Serves 32)$93.95$85.95 -
Chocolate Caramel Cup Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95 -
Chocolate Mint Chip Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95 -
On Sale
Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
(Serves 12)$56.95$51.95 -
On Sale
Holiday Eve / Holiday Morning Duo
(Serves 24)$93.95$87.95 -
On Sale
Basque Cheesecake with Cranberry Port Topping
(Serves 12)$52.95$47.95 -
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$53.95 -
Digital Gift Card
(Serves any)$0.00Buy Now Details -
Hot Chocolate Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95 -
$42.95
-
12 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$607.95 -
3 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$142.95 -
6 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$301.95 -
Strawberry-Topped Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$58.95 -
Tira Mi Su
(Serves 14)$66.95 -
Tower of Cheesecake
(Serves 40)$103.95 -
$62.95
-
C-CAKE - Design Your Own Cake
(Serves 16)$79.95Buy Now Details -
Vegan Belgian Chocolate "Cheesecake"
(Serves 10)$43.95 -
Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack
(Serves 12)$36.95 -
Apple Streusel Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$44.95 -
Chicago-Style Sampler
(Serves 12)$48.95Buy Now Details -
View for pricing
Buy Now Details -
DIY Wedding Cheesecake
(Serves 40)$165.95 -
Chocolate Cake
(Serves 12)$48.95 -
Mini Fudge Brownies
(Serves 12 brownies per box)$32.95 -
Cutie Dessert Sampler
(Serves 12 cuties per box)$42.95 -
Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut
(Serves 16)$53.95 -
Confetti Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95 -
Turtle Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$44.95 -
Basque Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$48.95Buy Now Details -
Vegan Lemon Raspberry "Cheesecake" Cuties
(Serves 12)$42.95 -
Vegan Belgian Chocolate "Cheesecake" Cuties
(Serves 12)$42.95 -
I Heart Cheesecake
(Serves 12)$54.95 -
Rep Your Colors Custom Cake
(Serves 16)$71.95Buy Now Details -
Chocolate Chip Cookie "Pie in the Sky"
(Serves 6)$15.95 -
Candy Cookie Crunch Sampler
(Serves 14)$68.95 -
Ruby Jubilee Cherry Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95 -
On Sale
Holiday Cuties Gift Set
(Serves 24 cuties per box)$72.95$64.95 -
Sweetheart Cuties
(Serves 12 cuties per box)$42.95 -
DIY Valentine's Day Dipper Kit
(Serves 6)$45.95 -
Original Plain Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$53.95 -
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95
