All Desserts
-
Original Plain Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$53.95Original Plain Cheesecake is the one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured... -
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$53.95Eli's creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust. -
Chocolate Lover's Sampler
(Serves 14)$62.95Please any chocolate lover with four to five slices each of our rich ... -
$62.95Caramel cheesecake loaded with Snickers® Bars and creamy caramel, topped with vanilla cream, a layer of rich...
-
Dynamic Duo Sampler - Half Plain, Half Chip
(Serves 16)$58.95Can't decide between Eli's two most popular flavors? Now you don't have to... just order Elis new combo... -
Digital Gift Card
(Serves any)$0.00The perfect gift for your favorite foodie! We'll email a code to your recipient, which they can use to shop online at...Buy Now Details -
Half & Half Sampler - Plain and Strawberry
(Serves 16)$58.95Two of our most popular flavors all in one cake! Get halfHot Chocolate Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95We've transformed the most decadent cup of hot chocolate into a dessert like no other. Eli's custom blend of milk and...$52.95BACK BY POPULAR DEMAND! The cheesecake lover's ultimate "Box of Chocolates." Miniature heart-shaped cheesecakes made...12 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$607.95Enjoy Eli's Cheesecake all year long! Sign up and receive a 9" Eli's Cheesecake every month for 12 months. After...3 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$142.95Get a different, delicious Eli's Cheesecake each month for three consecutive months! The first cheesecake will ship...6 Month Cheesecake Club
(Serves 14-16)$301.95Get a different, delicious Eli's Cheesecake each month for six consecutive months. The first cheesecake will ship the...Original Favorites Sampler
(Serves 16)$62.95Four slices each of our all-time favorite cheesecakes:Strawberry-Topped Cheesecake
(Serves 16)$58.95New Strawberry Topping Recipe! Eli's rich and creamy O...Tira Mi Su
(Serves 14)$66.95Eli's take on the classic Italian dessert made with espresso-infused sponge cake layered with clouds of mascarpone...C-CAKE - Design Your Own Cake
(Serves 16)Vegan Belgian Chocolate "Cheesecake"
(Serves 10)$43.95Dairy-free Cheesecake...yes, it's an oxymoron, but we've created a Vegan Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake so...Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack
(Serves 12)$36.95Our Apple and Cherry Mini Pies are the cutest mini pies on the planet...perfect for dessert buffets and as a plated...Carrot Cake
(Serves 12)$45.95A smaller version of our classic carrot cake recipe, enhanced with pineapple, golden raisins, crunchy walnuts and...Buffet Tower
(Serves 20)$93.95Wow your guests with an assortment of Eli's desserts. Includes one 9" Strawber...Cookbook Gift Packs
(Serves Varies)Original Plain Cheesecake - 8 inch
(Serves 14)$44.95A rich creamy cheesecake baked on an all-butter shortbread cookie crust. Made with pure Madagascar Vanilla.Cheesecake Cuties
(Serves 12 cuties per box)$42.95Created by Eli's granddaughter, Elana, Cuties are bite-sized pieces of Eli's Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate and...DIY Wedding Cheesecake
(Serves 40)$165.95For the DIY bride. Decorate your own wedding cheesecake and pop it in the fridge (up to 2 days in advance) until the...No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake
(Serves 12)$36.95A no sugar added version of our Original cheesecake, baked on a graham crust, made with Equal® Sweetener. Eli's...Mini Fudge Brownies
(Serves 12 brownies per box)$32.95Fudge Brownie Bites are a mini version of our famous scratch-recipe fudge brownie. Bite-sized, 1" x 1" bittersweet...Cutie Dessert Sampler
(Serves 12 cuties per box)$42.95Our Cutie Dessert Sampler contains bite-sized desserts in our most popular flavors; you'll get 4 of each: Raspberry...Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars
(Serves 10 bars per tin)$42.95Our double marshmallow crispy bars are the best crispy rice treat you'll ever have! A soft and chewy crispy rice...Cheesecake Cuties Gift Set
(Serves 24)$72.95The more the merrier! Enjoy 24 pieces of Eli's Cheese...Deep Dish Cheesecake
(Serves 8)$58.95Our Deep Dish Cheesecake is an Eli's dessert pizza: looks like your favorite Chicago-style deep dish, but it's...Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut
(Serves 16)$53.95No matter how you slice it...our Original Plain Cheesecake has been a Chicago legend for over 40 years. It's our...Confetti Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95It's a double celebration with a housemade layer of yellow confetti cake, topped with birthday cake confetti...Basque Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$48.95Our Basque Cheesecake is a riff on Eli's Original, inspired by the beloved dessert from Spain's Basque region. It's a...Halloween Dippers®
(Serves 7)$52.95Original Plain Cheesecake on a stick, hand-dipped in dark chocolate, decorated with spooktacular candy googly eyes (3...Pretty in Pink Cheesecake Dippers
(Serves 7)$52.95Think Pink! Original Plain Cheesecake on a stick, dipped in dark chocolate and hand-decorated with a pink chocolate...Vegan Lemon Raspberry "Cheesecake" Cuties
(Serves 12)$42.95Yes, it's an oxymoron, but we've created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn't resist calling it cheesecake! Made...Mini Macaroons
(Serves 12)$36.95We took our ever popular traditional coconut macaroons and made them mini! Our mini macaroons are hand-piped, baked...I Heart Cheesecake
(Serves 12)$54.95Heart-shaped vanilla cheesecake topped with tumbles of juicy whole raspberries and housemade raspberry glaze, baked...Rep Your Colors Cake - Design Your Own
(Serves 16)Ruby Jubilee Cherry Cheesecake
(Serves 14)$62.95A special edition cheesecake, celebrating our 40th anniversary! Rich vanilla cheesecake mixed with a mosaic of...DIY Monster Crispy Bar Kit
(Serves 8)$38.95It's fun (and easy) to dip and decorate these spooktacular Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars at home! Includes 8...Anniversary Tower
(Serves 40)$93.95Celebrate Eli's 40th anniversary with one 9" Ruby Jubilee Cheesecake, 12 Cuties Dessert Bars, and one box of 12...Chocolate Chip Cookie "Pie in the Sky"
(Serves 6)$15.95Is there anything better than a warm chocolate chip cookie? Turns out, there is. Our incredible pastry chefs have...
