Best Sellers

Best Sellers

Our most popular items, all in one place.

  • View as:
  • Sort by:
  • Per Page:
  • Original Plain Cheesecake

    Original Plain Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    The one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Ma... 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    OP9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Original Favorites Sampler

    Original Favorites Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Four slices each of our all-time favorite cheesecakes: Original Plain, Chocolate Chip, Strawberry, and Candy Bar made wi... 

    $47.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    OS9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cheesecake Cuties

    Cheesecake Cuties

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW SIZE! Created by Eli's granddaughter, Elana, Cuties are bite-sized pieces of Eli's Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate ... 

    $28.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    12CUTIES
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Tower of Cheesecake

    Tower of Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    A spectacular gift for any time of year. You'll receive one 9" Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, one 8" Turtle Cheesecake and o... 

    $82.95
     
    SERVES40  
    TW
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chicago-Style Sampler

    Chicago-Style Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Smaller Size, Same Great Flavors! Try 3 different flavors of Chicago's favorite dessert! 4 slices each of Chocolate Chip... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHISTYLE8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Elis creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust. 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    CC9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Strawberry Cheesecake

    Strawberry Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    New Strawberry Topping Recipe! Eli's rich and creamy Original Plain Cheesecake topped with juicy red strawberries, baked... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    SW9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Tira Mi Su

    Tira Mi Su

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's take on the classic Italian dessert made with espresso-infused sponge cake layered with clouds of mascarpone mouss... 

    $48.95 $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    TM9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dream Team Sampler

    Dream Team Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW FLAVORS! Enjoy three different flavors, all in one cake! A winning combination of Strawberry, Salted Caramel and Cho... 

    $52.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    DT29
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Midwest Sampler

    Midwest Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Four slices each of our Original Plain Cheesecake (Chicago's favorite dessert!), Apple Streusel Cheesecake and Cherry Li... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    MIDSAMP
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Neapolitan Tower

    Neapolitan Tower

    Availability: In Stock

    The classic combination of strawberry, vanilla and chocolate! One 7" Cookie, one 8" Original Plain and one 9" Strawberry... 

    $82.95
     
    SERVES40  
    NT
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.