$40 - $75

  • View as:
  • Sort by:
  • Per Page:
  • Apple Bavarian Tart

    Apple Bavarian Tart

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    As seen on the Food Network Unwrapped 2.0"! Caramelized fresh Michigan apple slices with a layer of Bavarian custard, ar... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    AB10
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Best of Eli's Gift Pack

    Best of Eli's Gift Pack

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    When your gift calls for the best of everything Eli's, this is it! One 7" Original Plain Cheesecake, one 9" Strawberry C... 

    $69.95
     
    SERVES34  
    BE
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Irish Cream Cheesecake

    Irish Cream Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Irish Cream cheesecake is layered with chocolate ganache and finished with Irish Cream mousse, a splash of chocolate and... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    BM10
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cookbook Gift Packs

    Cookbook Gift Packs

    Availability: In Stock

    Send an Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook with a delicious Eli's Cheesecake, all in one box! Choose your option below: 

    $
    9” 
    SERVESVaries  
    BOOKGIFT
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Blackberry Sour Cream Cheesecake

    Blackberry Sour Cream Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Our signature slow-cultured cream cheese combined with housemade Madagascar vanilla custard, topped with and intense cru... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES14  
    BS9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Buffet Tower

    Buffet Tower

    Availability: In Stock

    Wow your guests with a variety of Eli's desserts. Include one 9" Strawberry-topped Cheesecake, 12 mini pies (6 Apple & 6... 

    $61.95
     
    SERVES20  
    BUFTWR
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Carrot Cake

    Carrot Cake

    Availability: In Stock

    Our classic three-layer carrot cake is loaded with carrots, golden raisins, pineapple and walnuts, hand decorated with c... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    CARROT10
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Candy Cookie Crunch Sampler

    Candy Cookie Crunch Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    We've combined our Caramel Cheesecake made with Snickers Bars, Peanut Butter Cheesecake made with Reeses Peanut Butter C... 

    $49.95
     
    SERVES14  
    CCS30
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Lovers Sampler

    Chocolate Lovers Sampler

    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS CURRENTLY OUT OF STOCK. Please any chocolate lover with four to five slices each of our rich Candy Bar made... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES14  
    CLS9
     
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake made with Snickers® Bar

    Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake made with Snickers® Bar

    Availability: In Stock

    Caramel cheesecake loaded with Snickers® Bars and creamy caramel, topped with vanilla cream, a layer of rich chocola... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    CN9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cookie Crazy Cheesecake

    Cookie Crazy Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    America's #1 cookie and Chicago's favorite cheesecake! Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake with chunks of real Oreos®, t... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    CO9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cookie Butter Cheesecake

    Cookie Butter Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake swirled with rich cookie butter made with speculoos, topped with a velvety layer of more... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES14  
    COOKBUTR9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake made with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups®

    Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake made with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups®

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    A childhood favorite goes glam! Creamy peanut butter cheesecake bursting with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups®, topped w... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    CPB9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dream Team Sampler
    new item

    Dream Team Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! NEW FLAVORS! Enjoy three different flavors, all in one cake! A winning combination of Strawberry, Salted Caramel and Cho... 

    $49.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    DT29
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dynamic Duo Sampler

    Dynamic Duo Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Can't decide between Eli's two most popular flavors? Now you don't have to... just order Elis new combo cheesecake... h... 

    $40.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    DYNDUO
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Double Chocolate Cheesecake made with Ghirardelli® Chocolate

    Double Chocolate Cheesecake made with Ghirardelli® Chocolate

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    A thick slab of rich fudge brownie made with Ghirardelli® Cocoa topped with a layer of smooth and creamy chocolate c... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES14  
    GHIRA9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Half & Half Sampler

    Half & Half Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Two of our most popular flavors all in one cake! Get half Original Plain and half Strawberry cheesecake, 8 slices of eac... 

    $40.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    HH9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Hot Chocolate Cheesecake made with Gluten Free Ingredients

    Hot Chocolate Cheesecake made with Gluten Free Ingredients

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    We've transformed the most decadent cup of hot chocolate into a dessert like no other. Eli's custom blend of milk and da... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    HOTCHOC
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Half Strawberry/Half Chocolate Chip Sampler

    Half Strawberry/Half Chocolate Chip Sampler

    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS CURRENTLY OUT OF STOCK! Fruit or chocolate, can't decide? Now get a taste of both... just order Eli's NEW c... 

    $40.95
     
    SERVES16  
    HSHC9
     
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • Key Lime Pie Cheesecake

    Key Lime Pie Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's all natural slow cultured cream cheese and sour cream provide the perfect foil to the fresh tart flavor of real Fl... 

    $59.95
     
    SERVES14  
    KLPIE
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Lemon Mixed Berry Cheesecake

    Lemon Mixed Berry Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Refreshing lemon cheesecake studded with bits of lemon zest and layered with raspberries, blueberries, topped with cream... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    LM10
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Moscato Berry Tira Mi Su

    Moscato Berry Tira Mi Su

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Sweet red raspberries and blueberries layered with creamy mascarpone mousse and tender genoise soaked in Italian moscato... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    MB10
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Original Favorites Sampler

    Original Favorites Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Four slices each of our all-time favorite cheesecakes: Original Plain, Chocolate Chip, Strawberry, and Candy Bar made wi... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES16  
    OS9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Party Pack - Original/Sampler

    Party Pack - Original/Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    You'll get two cheesecakes, shipped in one box! Original Plain Cheesecake & Original Sampler. Each cake is pre-cut. O... 

    $72.95
     
    SERVES32  
    PARTYPACK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Party Pack-Strawberry/Sampler

    Party Pack-Strawberry/Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    You'll get two cheesecakes, shipped in one box! Strawberry Cheesecake & Original Sampler. Each cake is pre-cut. Origi... 

    $72.95
     
    SERVES32  
    PPACKSW
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Red Velvet Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Elis redefines this southern classic! A moist and subtle cocoa-flavored red velvet cake, a layer of rich and creamy red ... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    RV9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Salted Caramel Cheesecake made with Gluten Free Ingredients

    Salted Caramel Cheesecake made with Gluten Free Ingredients

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    This elegant cheesecake features the sophisticated and modern combination of salt and caramel. Creamy caramel cheesecake... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    SALTCARM
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Strawberry Cheesecake

    Strawberry Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    New Strawberry Topping Recipe! Eli's rich and creamy Original Plain Cheesecake topped with juicy red strawberries, baked... 

    $41.95
     
    SERVES16  
    SW9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Old-Fashioned Triple Chocolate Cake

    Old-Fashioned Triple Chocolate Cake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Three layers of homemade chocolate cake frosted with deep chocolate icing finished with a chocolate drizzle, hand-piped ... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    TCC10
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Tira Mi Su

    Tira Mi Su

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's take on the classic Italian dessert made with espresso-infused sponge cake layered with clouds of mascarpone mouss... 

    $45.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    TM9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Tres Leches Cake

    Tres Leches Cake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Tender genoise soaked in the traditional three milks, layered with rich creamy mousse and topped with a dusting of cocoa... 

    $45.95
     
    SERVES14  
    TRES9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Turtle Trio

    Turtle Trio

    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS CURRENTLY OUT OF STOCK! Chocolate, caramel and pecans abound in Eli's creamy caramel cheesecake loaded with... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    TTO9
     
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • Tuxedo Sampler

    Tuxedo Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Put your table on the Best Dressed List! 7 slices each of our Hot Chocolate Cheesecake and Double Chocolate Cheesecake m... 

    $48.95 $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    TUXSAMP
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Party Pack

    8" Party Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    Two 8" cheesecakes, shipped in one box! You'll get Eli's rich and creamy Original Plain Cheesecake and a sweet-tart Whit... 

    $49.95
    8” 
    SERVES28  
    8PPACK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Hazelnut Crisp Cheesecake

    Chocolate Hazelnut Crisp Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's housemade chocolate hazelnut spread, folded into rich dark chocolate cheesecake. Topped with a creamy layer of mor... 

    $44.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    HAZCRISP9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • DIY Birthday Kit
    new item

    DIY Birthday Kit

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! It's a party in a box! With this kit, you (or the recipient) can decorate an Original Plain Cheesecake with buttercream ... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES16  
    DIYBDAY
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Obsession Cheesecake
    new item

    Chocolate Obsession Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Four layers of chocolate decadence! Our richest chocolate cheesecake topped with creamy chocolate mousse, covered in bit... 

    $44.95 $34.95
    9” 
    SERVES14  
    CHOCOBS9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Eli's Signature Gift Pack
    new item

    Eli's Signature Gift Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Whatever the occassion, say it with Eli's! Our 5" Cheesecakes make the perfect gift anytime of year! You'll receive 4 Or... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES  
    SWOPPACK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Honey Almond Cheesecake

    Honey Almond Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Wildflower honey cheesecake, enhanced with the subtle addition of ricotta, is topped with a dreamy, crunchy layer of sal... 

    $59.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    HONMED
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Caramel Pecan Cheesecake

    Chocolate Caramel Pecan Cheesecake

    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS CURRENTLY OUT OF STOCK! Available for a Limited-Time Only! Rich caramel cheesecake hand-decorated with peca... 

    $41.95
     
    SERVES14  
    CAP9
     
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • College Combo

    College Combo

    Availability: In Stock

    Smaller in size (but not in flavor), it fits perfectly in a mini fridge! One 8" Original Plain Cheesecake and six Origin... 

    $44.95
     
    SERVES18  
    SPACK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake

    Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Replace ho-hum pumpkin pie with this elegant holiday dessert made with real pumpkin and seasonal spices, hand-decorated ... 

    $59.95 $39.95
    10” 
    SERVES14  
    PP10
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath® Toffee Bars

    Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath® Toffee Bars

    Availability: In Stock

    Creamy caramel cheesecake studded with Heath® Toffee Bars, topped with chocolate ganache and more Heath® Toffee ... 

    $41.95
     
    SERVES14  
    HB9
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • DIY C-CAKE

    DIY C-CAKE

    Availability: In Stock

    CREATE YOUR OWN CUSTOM CHEESECAKE! Simply select either Eli's Original Plain or Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, add your choi... 

    $61.95
     
    SERVES16  
    ccake
     
    Availability: In Stock