Under $40

  • View as:
  • Sort by:
  • Per Page:
  • Vegan Dairy-Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties
    new item

    Vegan Dairy-Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Certified Vegan, Plant-based, Cholesterol Free, Made With Tofu

    Made with semi-sweet Belgian chocolate and baked on a... 

    $28.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    VEGCUTIES
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars
    new item

    Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! The best crispy rice treat you'll ever have! A soft and chewy crispy rice cereal bar made with dark brown sugar, studded... 

    $32.95
     
    SERVES10 bars per tin  
    DBLMARSH
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Original Plain Cheesecake

    Original Plain Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    The one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Ma... 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    OP9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust. 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    CC9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dippers®

    Dippers®

    Availability: In Stock

    As seen on the Food Network Unwrapped 2.0! The hit of the Taste of Chicago, Americas largest food festival! Frozen Elis ... 

    $29.95
     
    SERVES6  
    ED
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • College Combo

    College Combo

    Availability: In Stock

    Smaller in size (but not in flavor), it fits in a mini fridge! One ... 

  • Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake

    Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Dairy-free Cheesecake...yes, it's an oxymoron, but we've created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn't resist callin... 

    $30.95
    7” 
    SERVES10  
    VEG7
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook

    Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook

    Availability: In Stock

    This cookbook, autographed by the author, includes 40 distinct cheesecake recipes, including Original Plain, Banana Choc... 

    $25.00
     
    SERVES  
    CBOOK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake

    No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    A no sugar added version of our Original cheesecake, baked on a graham crust, made with Equal® Sweetener. Eli's No S... 

    $22.95
    7” 
    SERVES12  
    NSAPLAIN
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Chocolate Cake

    8" Chocolate Cake

    Availability: In Stock

    Our classic, homemade chocolate cake is enhanced with deep chocolate icing and chocolate sprinkles. 

    $32.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHOCOLATE8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cheesecake Cuties

    Cheesecake Cuties

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW SIZE! Created by Eli's granddaughter, Elana, Cuties are bite-sized pieces of Eli's Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate ... 

    $28.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    12CUTIES
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack

    Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    The cutest mini pies on the planet...perfect for dessert buffets and as a plated dessert, a la mode. Apple Pie & Cherry... 

    $23.95
     
    SERVES12  
    PIEAC2
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Red Eli's T-Shirt

    Red Eli's T-Shirt

    Availability: In Stock

    Red t-shirt with Eli's logo 

    $14.00
     
    SERVES  
    REDT
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Double Dipper® Pack

    Double Dipper® Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    The hit of the Taste of Chicago, Americas largest food festival! Original ... 

    $39.95
     
    SERVES12  
    ED2
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Revolutionary Pyes

    Revolutionary Pyes

    Availability: In Stock

    The same Pyes as theater goers enjoy when seeing the Chicago production of Hamilton The Musical, are now available to yo... 

    $40.00
     
    SERVES12  
    REVPYE
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Original Plain Cheesecake

    8" Original Plain Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    A rich creamy cheesecake baked on an all-butter shortbread cookie crust. Made with pure Madagascar Vanilla. 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    OP8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Apple Streusel Cheesecake

    Apple Streusel Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's creamy Original Plain Cheesecake baked with fresh Michigan apples and a hint of cinnamon, topped with crunchy stre... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    ASTR8
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

    8" White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    White chocolate cheesecake topped with a mirror of red raspberry purèe and splash of white chocolate baked on a d... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    WCR8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Mini Macaroons
    new item

    Mini Macaroons

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! NEW SIZE! We took our ever popular traditional coconut macaroons and made them mini! Hand-piped and baked to a golden br... 

    $22.95
     
    SERVES12 macaroons per box  
    12MACAROON
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Brownie Bites
    new item

    Brownie Bites

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! NEW SIZE! A mini version of our famous scratch-recipe fudge brownie. Bite-sized, 1" x 1" bittersweet chocolate brownies ... 

    $19.95
     
    SERVES12 brownies per box  
    BROWNIECUTIES
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut
    new item

    Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! No matter how you slice it...our Original Plain Cheesecake has been a Chicago legend for over 40 years. It's our Origina... 

    $36.95
     
    SERVES16  
    PLAINUC
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Midwest Sampler

    Midwest Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK.

    Four slices each of our

    8” 
    SERVES12  
    MIDSAMP
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • 8 Carrot Cake

    8" Carrot Cake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: Out of Stock

    THIS ITEM IS TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK.

    A smaller version of our classic carrot cake recipe, enhanced with pineapple,... 

    $32.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CARROT8
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: Out of Stock
  • Cutie Dessert Sampler
    new item

    Cutie Dessert Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Bite-sized desserts in our most popular flavors; you'll get 4 of each:

    Raspberry Macaroon Bar: An all-butter shortbr... 

    $25.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    CUTIESAMP
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Celebration Sampler

    Celebration Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Celebrate the right way with Eli's Celebration Sampler! Three slices each of our most festive cheesecakes: Original Plai... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CSAMP8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cookie Cheesecake Double Pack
    new item

    Cookie Cheesecake Double Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Twice the deliciousness! Eli's original rich and creamy cheesecake covered in chunks of real Oreos® and a vanilla dr... 

    $39.95 $24.95
    7” 
    SERVES24  
    CO2
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Hot Chocolate Cheesecake Double Pack
    new item

    Hot Chocolate Cheesecake Double Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Twice the deliciousness! Rich milk chocolate cheesecake studded with bittersweet chocolate chunks, topped with clouds of... 

    $39.95 $24.95
    7” 
    SERVES24  
    HC2
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.