Under $40

  • View as:
  • Sort by:
  • Per Page:
  • Original Plain Cheesecake

    Original Plain Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    The one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Ma... 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    OP9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Elis creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust. 

    $39.95
    9” 
    SERVES16  
    CC9
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Mini Belgian Chocolate Hazelnut Cheesecake Hearts

    Mini Belgian Chocolate Hazelnut Cheesecake Hearts

    Availability: In Stock

    The cheesecake lover's ultimate "Box of Chocolates." Miniature heart-shaped cheesecakes made with deep, rich Belgian ch... 

    $39.95
     
    SERVES12  
    MINIBELG
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Turtle Heart Cheesecake

    Turtle Heart Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    One of our most popular flavors, all dressed up for Valentine's Day. Our creamy caramel cheesecake topped with bitterswe... 

    $31.95 $19.95
    7” 
    SERVES10  
    TURHEART
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • White Chocolate Raspberry Heart Cheesecake

    White Chocolate Raspberry Heart Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    Creamy white chocolate cheesecake topped with red raspberry gelee and whipped cream, baked on a chocolate crust in a hea... 

    $31.95 $19.95
    7” 
    SERVES10  
    WCRHEART
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dippers®

    Dippers®

    Availability: In Stock

    As seen on the Food Network Unwrapped 2.0! The hit of the Taste of Chicago, Americas largest food festival! Frozen Elis ... 

    $29.95
     
    SERVES6  
    ED
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • College Combo

    College Combo

    Availability: In Stock

    Smaller in size (but not in flavor), it fits perfectly in a mini fridge! One 8" Original Plain Cheesecake and six Origin... 

    $39.95
     
    SERVES18  
    SPACK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Daisy Cuties
    new item

    Daisy Cuties

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! The perfect dessert for any celebration! Bite-sized pieces of Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate and ... 

    $24.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    DAISY
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Midwest Sampler

    Midwest Sampler

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Four slices each of our Original Plain Cheesecake (Chicago's favorite dessert!), Apple Streusel Cheesecake and Cherry Li... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    MIDSAMP
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake

    Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Dairy-free Cheesecake...yes, it's an oxymoron, but we've created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn't resist callin... 

    $30.95
    7” 
    SERVES10  
    VEG7
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook

    Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook

    Availability: In Stock

    This cookbook, autographed by the author, includes 40 distinct cheesecake recipes, including Original Plain, Banana Choc... 

    $25.00
     
    SERVES  
    CBOOK
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • DIY Cheesecake Cuties Kit
    new item

    DIY Cheesecake Cuties Kit

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! It's fun (and easy) to dip and decorate your own Cuties, bite-sized Cheesecake squares. Includes everything you need to ... 

    $37.95
     
    SERVES24  
    DIYCUTIES
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake
    new item

    No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! A no sugar added version of our Original cheesecake, baked on a graham crust, made with Equal® Sweetener. Eli's No S... 

    $22.95
    7” 
    SERVES12  
    NSAPLAIN
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Carrot Cake
    new item

    8" Carrot Cake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Our classic carrot cake recipe, enhanced with pineapple, golden raisins, crunchy walnuts and smooth cream cheese frostin... 

    $32.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CARROT8
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Chocolate Cake
    new item

    8" Chocolate Cake

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Our classic, homemade chocolate cake is enhanced with deep chocolate icing and chocolate sprinkles. 

    $32.95 $26.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHOCOLATE8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cheesecake Cuties
    new item

    Cheesecake Cuties

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! NEW SIZE! Created by Eli's granddaughter, Elana, Cuties are bite-sized pieces of Eli's Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate ... 

    $25.95
     
    SERVES12 cuties per box  
    12CUTIES
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Brownie Bites

    Brownie Bites

    Availability: In Stock

    A mini version of our famous scratch-recipe fudge brownie. Bite-sized, 1" x 1" bittersweet chocolate brownies dusted wit... 

    $26.95
     
    SERVES20  
    BROWNBITE
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack

    Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    The cutest mini pies on the planet...perfect for dessert buffets and as a plated dessert, a la mode. Apple Pie & Cherry... 

    $21.95
     
    SERVES12  
    PIEAC2
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Red Eli's T-Shirt

    Red Eli's T-Shirt

    Availability: In Stock

    Red t-shirt with Eli's logo 

    $14.00
     
    SERVES  
    REDT
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Chicago-Style Sampler
    new item

    Chicago-Style Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Smaller Size, Same Great Flavors! Try 3 different flavors of Chicago's favorite dessert! 4 slices each of Chocolate Chip... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHISTYLE8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Celebration Sampler

    Celebration Sampler

    Availability: In Stock

    Celebrate the right way with Eli's Celebration Sampler! Three slices each of our cheesecakes: Original Plain, Apple Stre... 

    $34.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CSAMP8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Macaroons

    Macaroons

    Availability: In Stock

    This customer favorite is a chewy, moist, handmade toasted coconut cookie, dipped in rich chocolate. 

    $20.95
     
    SERVES12  
    MINIMAC
     
    Availability: In Stock
  • Double Dipper® Pack

    Double Dipper® Pack

    Availability: In Stock

    The hit of the Taste of Chicago, Americas largest food festival! Frozen Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake hand-dipped in r... 

    $39.95
     
    SERVES12  
    ED2
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Revolutionary Pyes
    new item

    Revolutionary Pyes

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! The same Pyes as theater goers enjoy when seeing the Chicago production of Hamilton The Musical, are now available to yo... 

    $40.00
     
    SERVES12  
    REVPYE
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Original Plain Cheesecake

    8" Original Plain Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    The one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Ma... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    OP8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
    new item

    8" Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Elis creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust. 8" Che... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHIP8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Apple Streusel Cheesecake

    Apple Streusel Cheesecake

    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock

    Eli's creamy Original Plain Cheesecake baked with fresh Michigan apples and a hint of cinnamon, topped with crunchy stre... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    ASTR8
     
    Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • Cherry Linzer Cheesecake
    new item

    Cherry Linzer Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    NEW! Juicy Michigan Montmorecy cherries and vanilla cheesecake, topped with golden brown streusel and baked on our all-butter... 

    $30.95
    8” 
    SERVES12  
    CHERRY8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.
  • 8 White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

    8" White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

    Availability: In Stock

    White chocolate cheesecake topped with a mirror of red raspberry purèe and splash of white chocolate baked on a d... 

    $30.95 $24.96
    8” 
    SERVES14  
    WCR8
     
    Availability: In Stock
    Qty.