Under $40
-
new item
Vegan Dairy-Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties
Availability: In StockNEW! Certified Vegan, Plant-based, Cholesterol Free, Made With Tofu
Made with semi-sweet Belgian chocolate and baked on a...
-
new item
Double Marshmallow Crispy Bars
Availability: In StockNEW! The best crispy rice treat you'll ever have! A soft and chewy crispy rice cereal bar made with dark brown sugar, studded...
-
Original Plain Cheesecake
Availability: In StockThe one that started it all...simply a combination of the best quality slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Ma...
-
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Availability: In StockEli's creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust.
-
-
College Combo
Availability: In StockSmaller in size (but not in flavor), it fits in a mini fridge! One ...
-
Dairy Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake
Availability: In StockDairy-free Cheesecake...yes, it's an oxymoron, but we've created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn't resist callin...
-
Eli's Cheesecake Cookbook
Availability: In StockThis cookbook, autographed by the author, includes 40 distinct cheesecake recipes, including Original Plain, Banana Choc...
-
No Sugar Added Plain Cheesecake
Availability: In StockA no sugar added version of our Original cheesecake, baked on a graham crust, made with Equal® Sweetener. Eli's No S...
-
8" Chocolate Cake
Availability: In StockOur classic, homemade chocolate cake is enhanced with deep chocolate icing and chocolate sprinkles.
-
Cheesecake Cuties
Availability: In StockNEW SIZE! Created by Eli's granddaughter, Elana, Cuties are bite-sized pieces of Eli's Cheesecake, enrobed in chocolate ...
-
Apple and Cherry Mini Pie Pack
Availability: In StockThe cutest mini pies on the planet...perfect for dessert buffets and as a plated dessert, a la mode. Apple Pie & Cherry...
-
-
Double Dipper® Pack
Availability: In StockThe hit of the Taste of Chicago, Americas largest food festival! Original ...
-
Revolutionary Pyes
Availability: In StockThe same Pyes as theater goers enjoy when seeing the Chicago production of Hamilton The Musical, are now available to yo...
-
8" Original Plain Cheesecake
Availability: In StockA rich creamy cheesecake baked on an all-butter shortbread cookie crust. Made with pure Madagascar Vanilla.
-
Apple Streusel Cheesecake
Availability: In StockEli's creamy Original Plain Cheesecake baked with fresh Michigan apples and a hint of cinnamon, topped with crunchy stre...
-
8" White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
Availability: In StockWhite chocolate cheesecake topped with a mirror of red raspberry purèe and splash of white chocolate baked on a d...
-
new item
Mini Macaroons
Availability: In StockNEW! NEW SIZE! We took our ever popular traditional coconut macaroons and made them mini! Hand-piped and baked to a golden br...
-
new item
Brownie Bites
Availability: In StockNEW! NEW SIZE! A mini version of our famous scratch-recipe fudge brownie. Bite-sized, 1" x 1" bittersweet chocolate brownies ...
-
new item
Original Plain Cheesecake - Uncut
Availability: In StockNEW! No matter how you slice it...our Original Plain Cheesecake has been a Chicago legend for over 40 years. It's our Origina...
-
Midwest Sampler
Availability: Out of StockTHIS ITEM IS TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK.
Four slices each of our
$34.958”SERVES12MIDSAMP
Availability: Out of Stock
8" Carrot Cake
Availability: Out of StockTHIS ITEM IS TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK.
A smaller version of our classic carrot cake recipe, enhanced with pineapple,...
new item
Cutie Dessert Sampler
Availability: In StockNEW! Bite-sized desserts in our most popular flavors; you'll get 4 of each:
Raspberry Macaroon Bar: An all-butter shortbr...
Celebration Sampler
Availability: In StockCelebrate the right way with Eli's Celebration Sampler! Three slices each of our most festive cheesecakes: Original Plai...
new item
Cookie Cheesecake Double Pack
Availability: In StockNEW! Twice the deliciousness! Eli's original rich and creamy cheesecake covered in chunks of real Oreos® and a vanilla dr...
new item
Hot Chocolate Cheesecake Double Pack
Availability: In StockNEW! Twice the deliciousness! Rich milk chocolate cheesecake studded with bittersweet chocolate chunks, topped with clouds of...